The name doesn’t really do these justice. “Peanut butter sandwich” sounds so humdrum… satisfactory but unexciting, adequate but kind of elementary… but these are so much more! To know them is to love them, and if you’ve had one at The Most Magical Place On Earth, you have felt the rollercoaster of emotions as their sandwich saga unfolded.
You see, they were a popular Disneyland treat, always found in Pooh’s Corner and in most of the candy shops throughout the park. Then, for some inexplicable reason, they were discontinued. But suddenly, hope was restored! They were brought back for a trial run and we innocently thought that meant they were here to stay, forever and always. But no, it was too good to be true. They were discontinued again.
We don’t know about you, but we don’t want to live an entire lifetime without this magical bar made up of graham crackers, peanut butter, and chocolate. And luckily we don’t have to. Because they’re easy enough to make at home. See for yourself:
You start by lining the bottom of a baking pan with graham crackers and then topping that layer with melted chocolate. A mixture of peanut butter (and some other good stuff) gets spread on top before it’s stacked with more chocolate and more graham crackers and a little more chocolate. Then it chills until the chocolate has set and you slice it up into bars to serve.
Chocolate. Graham Crackers. Peanut Butter. It seems so simple, but there’s just something magical about this trio. The crackers retain a bit of crunch against the smooth bite of the peanut butter and sweet chocolate. We will never understand why Disney let them go, but in our home, they’re definitely here to stay.
Please continue to Next Page (>) for the full list of ingredients and complete cooking instructions.